Are any of these broths compliant?

[Atss13]

Are any of these broths below compliant?  Thank you!

 

Beef Broth - https://www.kettleandfire.com/our-bone-broth

Marrow bones from pasture raised, grass-fed cows, organic carrots, organic onions, organic celery, organic bay leaves, organic parsley, apple cider vinegar, a pinch of black peppercorn, sea salt, thyme and rosemary extract.

 

 

Beef Broth - https://www.barebonesbroth.com/product/beef.html

NGREDIENTS: FILTERED WATER, ORGANIC BEEF, ORGANIC TOMATO PUREE, ORGANIC ONION, ORGANIC GARLIC, ORGANIC PARSLEY, ORGANIC THYME, SEA SALT, ORGANIC BAY LEAF, ORGANIC THYME, BLACK PEPPER, ROSEMARY EXTRACT.

 

Chicken Broth -   http://bit.ly/1ZnhjHa

• Chicken Stock (Water, Chicken)
• Onion
• Cider Vinegar
• Rosemary Extract

 

 

 

[jmcbn]

Yep, they all look good to me 

[kirkor]

What ingredients were you unsure of?

[Atss13]

I am new to Whole30 and read an older forum thread that stated there weren't ANY broths that could be purchased that would be compliant. It went on to state that you would have to make your own broths to be truly compliant. That is what was confusing to me, since the ingredients listed didn't seem to be off limits???

 

Thank you both for your replies!

[laura_juggles]

Older threads are good if you're looking for whether or not some specific additive is permissible. But when it comes to entire product categories like broths or nut milks, it's better to look at today's list of noncompliant ingredients and the package in your hand. 

 

Remember, that there are older threads that say white potatoes are not compliant.

[ShannonM816]

I am new to Whole30 and read an older forum thread that stated there weren't ANY broths that could be purchased that would be compliant. It went on to state that you would have to make your own broths to be truly compliant. That is what was confusing to me, since the ingredients listed didn't seem to be off limits???

Thank you both for your replies!

In the last few years it's gotten easier to find pre-made products that are compliant.

Broth is actually easy to make, and generally, the homemade stuff tastes better, so I'd really recommend trying it sometime if you haven't before.

[aphid180]

I am new to Whole30 and read an older forum thread that stated there weren't ANY broths that could be purchased that would be compliant. It went on to state that you would have to make your own broths to be truly compliant. That is what was confusing to me, since the ingredients listed didn't seem to be off limits???

 

Thank you both for your replies!

Looks like Kettle & Fire is whole30 approved. They're listed on their approved products page. Also is the only non-frozen bone broth I've come across.