mrsm14

Crystal Deodorant- Bad news?

Recommended Posts

I know the natural deodorant thread already exists, but I feel this is a really important issue that is coming out of that thread that might need to be addressed separately (not a Whole30 question, but smelly pits are an important issue for us all!)

Based on the natural deodorant thread, I bought a crystal deodorant, (which works great) only to find out that the main ingredient is 'potassium alum', which is a NATURAL FORM OF ALUMINUM. I think that everyone should do their own research on this issue (googling "Crystal Deodorant Aluminum" will give you a head start), but I'm feeling based on the info out there that this natural form of aluminum should in theory be just as bad as a more 'manufactured' aluminum in antiperspirants and not be used by members of this forum trying to do the right thing by using a natural deodorant.

Right after discontinuing the crystal, I started using extra virgin coconut oil, which has been amazing! It's going well and lasting at least 12 hours, which is all I need to get through work.

Anyone have thoughts or their own research on this topic? I feel very duped by the advertising for this crystal deodorant.

Thanks ladies!

Share this post


Link to post

My husband is a chemist and has said for years that he believes the crystal is just as bad. I wish coconut oil worked for me. I've tried many different combos of natural deodorant. I haven't found anything that works for me yet without irritation.

Share this post


Link to post

Well that's disappointing news. I really like the crystal. It is the only thing that I have ever tried that has worked so well.

Share this post


Link to post

Questions: Are your pits greasy when you use coconut oil? Do your clothes get stained? Do you sweat less, or sweat normal?

:)

Share this post


Link to post

*sigh* the crystal is the only thing I've ever used that doesn't cause a rash (baking soda and tom's of maine both do). Anyone have any sensitive skin suggestions?

Share this post


Link to post

I sometimes use just extra virgin coconut oil, and I've never had a problem with staining clothing, however, I don't wear silk or wool or anything very delicate.

I've been having great results with Pitty Party (buy on etsy) and Funk Butter.

Share this post


Link to post

The coconut oil goes on greasy but absorbs rather quickly (I use it for moisturizer on my legs as well). I haven't had stains on any clothing items. It lasts a good 10-12 hours on a normal 'business day' ( I work in an office). I sweat the same, and I reapply before evening workouts. I think the issue is that all of us who have used/were accustomed to a normal deodorant (with aluminum) are on a futile quest to find something that works just as well. sigh.

Share this post


Link to post

Questions: Are your pits greasy when you use coconut oil? Do your clothes get stained? Do you sweat less, or sweat normal?

:)

I have made my own deodorant bar with coconut oil, rhassoul mud, and beeswax. For my husband and I, it does leave oil stains that do not wash out on our clothes (mostly cotton shirts) :-( The crystal was the only thing that worked for me as well. Anything with baking soda in it gives me an instant firey rash.

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now